The end of the primary season provides us hypocrisy scholars with an opportunity to step back and study the Big Picture. We have been witness to breathtaking feats of hypocrisy on all sides of the political spectrum.
We have seen the candidates’ paid spokespersons spin dizzying rings around the truth to equally phony anchors on TV non-news shows that are sponsored by companies that pay huge dollars to other companies to make lying commercials about hair-goo and sexless
sedans. We shall soon see more.
But none of that bothers us much, because it’s mild and harmless hypocrisy, for the most part. When Hillary makes her concession speech Saturday and spends the
next few months playing kissyface with Barack like they never said a bad word or had a bad thought about each other we shan’t be surprised. It’s hypocritical, but it’s the way of the world.
More specifically, it’s the way of the warrior. The closest analogy in “real life” is boxing. Two men who have spent twelve weeks verbally shredding and twelve rounds physically pounding each other into raw, bloody hulks, invariably end the contest with a nice, sweet hug.
Do they mean it? I don’t know, maybe, maybe not. But I wouldn’t have it any other way, whether it’s belts or hats in the ring. Making nice might be phony, even hypocritical, but it’s nice.
That is lesson one in today’s lecture in Advanced Hypocrisy. All hypocrisy is not equal. There are degrees of hypocrisy, from the mild and benign to the vicious and malignant. Some hypocrisy is merely politeness, or method of conflict resolution that allows the winner to feel good and the loser to save face. This is gentle, Level One, hypocrisy. Saying something you don’t quite mean to make someone else feel better may be a hypocritical lie, but it is not evil.
Then there is the case of the bald-faced lie told with the best of intentions. A coke dealer tells his fourteen-year-old daughter that he never, ever smoked dope, and neither should she. This is Level Two hypocrisy. It is well-meaning, but dangerous, because when the truth comes out, as it invariably will, it can do damage. If you lied about the weed maybe you’re lying about the smack, she’ll think.
What these two, mild levels of hypocrisy have in common is that they’re committed to help others, to protect them from the embarrassment of your true thoughts or the danger of your true deeds. They are basically selfless acts—any bad effects they may have are unintentional. But there are darker, more sinister levels of hypocrisy. If Level One is a victimless crime, and Level Two a misdemeanor, the next two levels are manslaughter and murder. Levels Three and Four will be the subject of our next lecture. Bring your sharpest pencils and be ready to take notes.
Things are about to get serious.
No comments:
Post a Comment